I would just like to know the rule for which. The key factor is that the version with the comma implies that security is well defined is a property of all message codes whereas the version without the comma implies that security is well defined is a property only of some message codes.
Comma Before Which When To Put A Comma Before Which 7esl
People often get muddled about whether to place a comma before.
. You dont add a comma when which comes before a restrictive or defining clause. You use a comma when the word which introduces a nonrestrictive phrase which is also called a non-defining clause. The answer depends on how you are using or.
The games the longest of which lasted two hours were fun. Thats a pretty dodgy proposition my friend. Always place a comma before or when it begins an independent clause but if it begins a dependent clause dont.
The computer which I bought yesterday has broken down already. When which appears in a prepositional phrase it should not be preceded by a comma. Are restoring an old townhouse which will serve as a display shop for the.
If its nonrestrictive then set off with comma s. This kind of clause starting with a which always requires a. Answer 1 of 23.
Other examples of which in a prepositional phrase are on which and of which Correct. In the OPs sentence the which clause is non-defining so the comma is needed. However in the British style of writing a comma is inserted before but not after ie.
Simply put you should use a comma before which when it precedes a nonrestrictive modifying clause. In a series or list of three or more items you can use a comma before or but this is a preference not a rule. Are you using Quora to do your English class homework.
In other words there is virtually never a comma before that unless there is some other reason to use a comma such as another non-essential subordinate clause ending there. The sentence is a complete sentence through skills The additional information following that is known as a nonrestrictive or appositive clause. It seems that the use of comma is found more often in American English and even there it is not always required.
Youll probably get a couple contradictory responses youll blindly pick the one that sounds best to you and maybe get a good grade and maybe not. Same rule whether the which phrase appears in the middle or at the end. Its normally set off from the rest of a sentence with commas.
There is also a prescriptive rule in American English commonly quoted as. Its often used to identify one thing amongst a larger set. In the US which without a comma is always replaced with that or deleted.
Answer 1 of 9. If that works your phrase is restrictive and you dont need comma s If that doesnt work your phrase is nonrestrictive and you need comma s Theres nothing. The games the longest of which lasted two hours were fun.
The comma which can be difficult to use correctly is. A coordinating conjunction is used to connect words phrases and clauses. It is additional information.
Scounted the possibilities at Countrywide Motor Sales which sells used sedans station wagons and pickup trucks. Brits are increasingly following that trend too The fruit which I bought on Tuesday has turned rotten. Is there always a comma before which in a sentence such as - -.
Try to substitute that for which. Show activity on this post. Do not use a comma before which if you could replace your which with that Use a comma before which if just provides additional information.
If the which clause is a defining clause then no comma is required. Here are some examples of defining which clauses. In the American style of writing a comma is inserted before and after ie.
A nonrestrictive modifying clause is a phrase that adds nonessential information to a sentence without altering its meaning. I came through a sentence that comma precedes in which but I have heard that no comma precedes which that has a preposition before it. The team in which we played was great.
Of those four uses youll only need to use a comma before. The comma should be placed after the first clause and before the coordinating conjunction. The word can be used as part of a nonrestrictive phrase restrictive phrase or prepositional phrase and it can be used as an interrogative word.
Application of Hennigs winnow therefore supported a different cladogram in which tarantulas and their allies Mygalomorphae are more closely related to typical spiders. If the which clause is not a defining clause then the comma is required. The word which has a few different use cases in the English language.
There is no comma when which forms an indirect or direct question or is part of a prepositional phrase.
Comma Before Which Where And Who When To Use It With Examples
Comma Before Which When To Put A Comma Before Which 7esl
When To Use Comma Before Which Youtube
Should I Use A Comma Before Which The Grammar Guide
0 Comments